home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=93TT0848>
- <title>
- Sep. 20, 1993: The Season of the Stand-Ups
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1993
- Sep. 20, 1993 Clinton's Health Plan
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- TELEVISION, Page 78
- The Season of the STAND-UPS
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>On the fall lineup, you don't have to be a star to get a showcase
- </p>
- <p>By RICHARD ZOGLIN
- </p>
- <p> It's the time of year to feel sorry for the TV networks. Each
- fall, the Big Three manufacture a fresh batch of shows and try
- to generate some new-season excitement, and each year the job
- gets tougher. The audience wants something different; critics
- clamor for "innovation." But how many new concepts are left
- in a cable-saturated world where viewers have seen everything--and seen it all over again in reruns? Judging by a fall crop
- dominated by play-it-safe family sitcoms, not many.
- </p>
- <p> There are always, however, new stars. TV's creative food chain
- lately has been turned upside down. Producers once dreamed up
- concepts and then looked for actors to flesh them out. Now,
- more often, the stars come first and the shows are built around
- them. It's the season of the star vehicle, the series built
- to a performer's specifications. What matters is the showcase,
- not the show.
- </p>
- <p> Vehicles, of course, are as old as television itself. I Love
- Lucy, Mary Tyler Moore and The Cosby Show were well-designed
- showpieces for popular performers. But never have stars been
- so firmly in the driver's seat. Faye Dunaway, making her weekly-TV
- debut, appears in a made-to-order sitcom this fall. So do such
- TV veterans as John Larroquette, Valerie Bertinelli, Bronson
- Pinchot and Kelsey Grammer. Another group of shows has been
- constructed around performers with no track record, no Q rating,
- not even (in many cases) any acting experience at all, except
- on the stand-up comedy stage.
- </p>
- <p> The sudden vogue for stand-up comedians is based on solid Nielsen
- evidence. First Roseanne and later Seinfeld, Home Improvement
- and Martin showed that joking at the Improv can be a springboard
- to prime-time success. Now producers and studio executives are
- scouring the comedy clubs for the next Tim Allen or Martin Lawrence.
- "It's a feeding frenzy," says a comedy producer. "A lot of these
- people you might cast as the second or third lead in an ensemble.
- But now, the studios want to build shows around them."
- </p>
- <p> For an idea-starved industry, the club comics bring some important
- assets. Even without acting credentials, they know how to get
- laughs. Often they have developed a stage persona, or an attitude,
- or at the very minimum a few well-tested gag lines. Yet delivering
- one-liners is not the same as creating a character. For every
- comic who has made a successful transition to prime time, there
- are others (Jackie Mason, Richard Lewis) who have been sabotaged
- by their own limitations or by the rickety contraptions built
- for them.
- </p>
- <p> Thea Vidale, for example, is a big, boisterous comic with a
- lot of stage presence--or, at least, presence over a lot of
- the stage. Unfortunately, her ABC sitcom, Thea, is a throwback
- to the broad, brackish family sitcoms of the Good Times ilk:
- streetwise sass drenched in sentimental mush. John Mendoza,
- who plays a newly divorced sportswriter in NBC's The Second
- Half, is a mellower, and less accomplished, performer, who is
- also defeated by tired gag situations--the inept single guy
- who can't furnish an apartment or get a date without stumbling
- over his feet.
- </p>
- <p> Caryl Kristensen and Marilyn Kentz bring more freshness and
- vitality to NBC's The Mommies. Housewives from Petaluma, California,
- they began doing a stand-up act three years ago, giving voice
- to their suburban-mom woes. Now they play next-door neighbors
- with the usual assortment of kids and spouses. The pair work
- together like seasoned pros, but the rabid man bashing is overwrought,
- and too many of the jokes seem to have been unloaded directly
- from their comedy-club trunk. (On being given drugs during labor:
- "That epidural was better than the sex that got me there.")
- As vehicles go, The Mommies does not seem conditioned for the
- long haul.
- </p>
- <p> Of all the stand-up-inspired sitcoms, ABC's Grace Under Fire
- may have the best chance for survival. Brett Butler, a big-boned,
- Alabama-born comic, plays a divorced mother raising three kids
- while holding down a job at the local oil refinery. Once again,
- the stand-up material is too easy to spot. Discussing her abusive
- ex-husband, Grace unloads a torrent of put-downs: "His idea
- of foreplay was waking me up...He moved his lips while reading
- stop signs." But Butler projects easygoing authenticity, and
- the program has a good grip on the dogged drama of single motherhood.
- </p>
- <p> Turning shows over to amateurs, however, can be treacherous.
- Starring in ABC's George is former heavyweight boxing champ
- and TV neophyte George Foreman. Cast (surprise) as an ex-heavyweight
- champ who works with problem kids in an after-school program,
- he stiffly delivers lines that are as subtle as a punch in the
- ribs. "End round one," he says after an encounter with the incorrigibles.
- "I took some shots, but I ain't down yet." The series, however,
- is already flat on the mat.
- </p>
- <p> Even competent performers can falter when they step into the
- star spot for the first time. Fran Drescher got a few laughs
- as the Jewish member of a trio of New York City roommates in
- the failed sitcom Princesses. In CBS's The Nanny, she takes
- her Long Island whine into a stuffy Brahmin household and turns
- it into a grating one-note samba. Valerie Bertinelli, playing
- an American in Paris, exceeds her perkiness allotment even before
- her plane lands in NBC's Cafe Americain. And CBS's The Trouble
- with Larry, in which a missing adventurer reappears after 10
- years and moves in with his wife and her new husband, seems
- to exist for the sole purpose of showing off Bronson Pinchot's
- frenetic "versatility."
- </p>
- <p> Faye Dunaway doesn't have to prove her versatility, but she
- should have had better sense than to get trapped in a contrivance
- like It Had to Be You. As a high-powered book publisher who
- gets romantically involved with a divorced carpenter (Robert
- Urich), Dunaway struts through the show with confidence. But
- she is forced to participate in clumsy slapstick set pieces
- and react to bad wisecracks about her sex life. Nosy secretary:
- "Find yourself a man who'd rather be on top of you than the
- Times best-seller list."
- </p>
- <p> Yet most of the bright spots on the fall schedule can be traced
- to stars. Family Album (CBS) might be dismissed as just another
- shrill family sitcom were it not for Peter Scolari (Newhart)
- and Pamela Reed (Tanner '88), playing a couple who move their
- family back East to be closer to their aging parents. Everyone
- on the show is wired, from a TV-mesmerized son ("Joan Lunden's
- hair! What is she thinking?") to a splenetic, cigar-smoking
- grandfather ("I don't get it. You have your third heart attack,
- and everybody panics"). In the midst of this mayhem, Reed and
- Scolari keep their cool wits about them and help deliver the
- season's funniest half-hour.
- </p>
- <p> John Larroquette is another TV star who has learned that less
- is often more in the hectic world of TV comedy. In his new NBC
- sitcom, the four-time Emmy winner (Night Court) plays a recovering
- alcoholic who takes a job as night manager of a seedy St. Louis
- bus station. The show's wryly dispirited ambiance is reflected
- in an old amusement park sign hanging in his office: THIS IS
- A DARK RIDE. Even when the supporting cast goes over the top,
- Larroquette, with his lived-in face and low-key assurance, brings
- everything down to his own comfortable rhythm.
- </p>
- <p> Larroquette's co-star from Night Court, Harry Anderson, is just
- as understated and engaging in CBS's Dave's World. This is a
- rare sitcom that exists to showcase not a star but a writer.
- Anderson plays humor columnist Dave Barry, a beleaguered family
- man facing a classic baby-boomer problem: trying to raise three
- kids while grappling with the realization that he is no longer
- a kid himself. He sings I Am the Walrus in the shower (then
- looks at his body and exclaims, "I am the walrus!"), and can't
- get up the fatherly gumption to force his son to play soccer.
- Dave's World is the most charmingly laid-back sitcom of the
- new season, mainly because Anderson handles his vehicle shrewdly.
- He's not in a race; he's just out for a spin.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-